
When Maiko Lehman moved into her two-bedroom, seventh-floor apartment in Chicago’s Edgewater neighborhood in 2022, she was thrilled with the updated kitchen and all the windows in the corner unit.
She had to get a roommate so she could afford her bills, but the two of them knew exactly what they owed the landlord every month: the rent plus a flat fee of $100 to cover gas, water and trash services.
“It was a known fee,” said Lehman, 56. “It was in the lease, and you knew it when you moved in.”
Then, in 2024, the building changed hands, and property management announced it would start using a “ratio utility billing system” — better known as RUBS.
The landlord outsourced the billing to a third-party company called Conservice, which splits up the master gas, sewer and water bills according to a formula based on the size of the apartment, the number of occupants, and other factors. Conservice then tacks on a service fee and sends the bill out to renters.
Since her building switched to RUBS, Lehman’s monthly utility bills have ranged from $88.05 to $225.57. She never knows what the total bill will be — nor is she sure the property management isn’t charging more than it should. She’s tried to get them to tell her the formula, but to no avail.
She said she can try to conserve gas and water, but she’s still charged based on whatever the totals are for the entire property. If there are leaky toilets or drafty windows throughout the building, it’s her and her neighbors — not the landlord — bearing the cost for the higher utility bills. In fact, Lehman thinks RUBS disincentivizes management from making timely repairs.
Many of her neighbors with limited incomes are struggling, and some have even had to move out, Lehman added.
“There’s people in the building now who are flirting with [whether] they can afford the rent, and all of a sudden, this month the bill is higher for the utilities,” she said.
WBEZ reached out to Berkshire Residential, the property manager for Lehman’s building, but has not received a response.
Lehman is among the estimated tens of thousands of Chicago renters living in a building that uses RUBS. Consumer advocates and tenant organizations say this way of billing is becoming more of a trend in master-metered apartment buildings all over the city — those buildings that don’t have separate water and gas meters for each unit. And as utility costs continue to climb, tenants are trying to keep up with the fluctuating bills while struggling to get answers from their landlords. Furthermore, experts say there is little recourse for tenants because existing laws on utility billing don’t go far enough.
A lack of regulation
Neither Chicago’s Department of Buildings nor the Department of Housing tracks how many buildings use ratio utility billing.
In the majority of these master-metered apartment buildings, landlords still estimate the costs and bake them into the rent — or they charge a consistent, flat fee on top of rent that is disclosed in the lease.
But experts say rising utility costs, plus the proliferation of companies like Conservice that offer property management software and billing services, which are heavily marketed to owners, are pushing more landlords to switch to RUBS.
“RUBS basically shifts risk of volatile, rising utility costs off of the landlords and onto the tenants,” said Olivia Wein, a senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center. “There are now many RUBS companies developing these products for landlords. At the same time, people are experiencing unaffordability — the cost of everything is going up.”
Now, more and more apartment renters are getting bills from companies like Conservice, Yes Energy Management, and Synergy Utility BIlling.
Wein said there are currently no laws in Illinois that ban the use of RUBS, and there is no agency regulating the billing companies.
A spokesperson for the Illinois Commerce Commission, which regulates utility companies, said in a statement that it “does not have authority over ratio metering. This would be a tenant-landlord matter.”
Wein, with NCLC, said “because of the lack of transparency and the newness of [RUBS], and the lack of a clear regulator in this space, it’s an opportunity for abuses to proliferate.”
Illinois has some laws on the books related to utility billing, but Wein said they don’t go far enough. For example, Illinois requires landlords give notice to tenants before switching to RUBS, and renters have a right to see the master utility bills. The city of Chicago does not have RUBS-related ordinances on the books, although Mayor Brandon Johnson’s Protecting Renters Ordinance, currently before City Council, seeks to codify some of the same protections as the state laws.
Meanwhile, organizations like NCLC, as well as tenant rights and legal aid groups, have said they are getting more calls from frustrated tenants who can’t get answers from their landlords about their RUBS bills. And for now, there is little recourse because it’s difficult to find lawyers to take on cases related to RUBS, and it’s not easy to organize a tenant union to take collective action.
Conservice did not respond to questions about its billing services. The company’s page on the Better Business Bureau website has received more than 150 reviews that average one out of five stars.
WBEZ also reached out to landlord groups in Chicago. The Neighborhood Building Owners Alliance said only about 10% of its members use RUBS in their buildings.
A spokesperson for the Illinois Apartment Association, another landlord and property manager organization, said in a statement: “RUBS provides an accurate estimate based on actual usage. A fair, transparent, and consistent RUBS formula promotes resident conservation, encourages responsible utility usage, and creates management efficiencies that reduce upward pressure on rent.”
But consumer advocates and tenant groups say that’s not true.
“The tenant’s bill is not tied to actual tenant usage,” Wein said.
In some cases, tenants would go out of town for weeks but return to higher gas and water bills.
Wein said the issue extends beyond Illinois. Several states and municipalities throughout the U.S. have tried to address challenges related to RUBS with varying degrees of success. She said some states, like Connecticut, have banned RUBS; others limit landlords to using specific formulas and have an agency that settles landlord-tenant disputes. Currently, there are also efforts in cities like Seattle and Los Angeles to ban the use of ratio utility billing systems.
“It is very hard to craft a comprehensive consumer protection law when it comes to [RUBS],” Wein said, adding that this billing practice could lead to more evictions throughout the country. “Really the safest thing to do to protect tenant housing affordability is just to prohibit the practice right now.”
Tenants fight back
Ending this billing practice is exactly what 85-year-old Viola Davis wants.
She first moved into the Oglesby Towers high-rise in Chicago’s South Shore neighborhood eight years ago. For years, she paid a flat fee of $105 for utilities on top of her rent for her one-bedroom apartment.
“I thought when I moved here, I could afford this building,” Davis said.
Since early this year, when her landlord, Stuart Handler and TLC Management, switched the building to RUBS, Davis has had to pay anything from around $150 to more than $220 in utilities per month.
She has struggled to make ends meet using her pension and social security funds, not knowing whether she’ll have enough to buy her groceries or give her great grandson his birthday money.
So Davis started talking to her neighbors — many of them fellow senior citizens on a fixed income — and found that some saw bills as high as $500.
The neighbors contacted community organizing nonprofit Southside Together and formed a tenant union. They held their first press conference in August, and sent a letter to TLC demanding a meeting.
Housing organizer Savannah Brown said the tenants’ efforts led to management reversing a trash fee, but that the group will continue to push to get rid of RUBS.
“RUBS is essentially a variable rent increase,” Brown said. “This is just another thing to push out folks who have been in the neighborhood for the longest, who have been in this building for decades.”
WBEZ reached out to Handler and TLC Management but has not received a response.
Last month, the Oglesby tenants held a second press conference. One resident, 63-year-old Antoinette Gray, said she was being evicted because she couldn’t keep up with the bills.
“When Stuart Handler started RUBS, it had a real impact on me, my life, everything,” Gray said. “I’ve done the best I could to stay here. Their response has been, ‘If you can’t pay, just leave.’”
IUSTITIA.BG – Investigations 2009-2026 2026-11-17 01:39:01
Latest news World news Country news Most important news latest news most important latest of the day Justice Petar Nizamov Feathers Petar Nizamov- Feathers Justice bg iustitia.bg iustitia iusticia usticia investigation Burgas Bulgaria news news of the last hour news of the day news of today Bulgaria news The news from Bulgaria blitz news top news most important most commented latest news Boyko Borisov news weather coronavirus news news weather facebook youtube facebook instagram news today news of the last minutes news today today news news bg news leading news hot news bg news site for news all news news bg news of the last hour latest latest news bg news of today news today news today news of the last hour latest news today news bg news news 24 hours news vesti bg novini news world bird bg bivol bg bivol trud bg novini latest news today novinite bg news hello bulgaria political party coat of arms delyan peevski scandalous Bulgarian National Television Free Europe Television scandal exclusive live tv live right now tv tv online tv program bg live now tv news online tv online live court Burgas court Burgas district court Burgas court Burgas district court Burgas district court Burgas appellate court Burgas prosecutor Burgas prosecutor’s office Burgas district prosecutor’s office Burgas district prosecutor’s office Burgas district prosecutor’s office Burgas district prosecutor’s office Burgas district prosecutor’s office Burgas district prosecutor’s office Prosecutor General Ivan Geshev Prosecutor Geshev Tsatsarov Ministry of Internal Affairs Burgas ODMR Burgas ODPR Burgas police Burgas district police Burgas prosecutor Tsatsarov SGS cases Varna court chairman of the SGS court decisions on civil cases decisions on cases Plovdiv court decision of the court decisions cases Varna court criminal cases district district court decisions work in the court SGS chairman of the SGS judges Sofia court post judges Plovdiv court Plovdiv judges Plovdiv Supreme Court Inspectorate Supreme Court Supreme Judicial Council lawyer lawyer criminal cases lawyer civil cases lawyer marriage cases lawyer administrative criminal law criminal process civil law civil process administrative law constitutional law




